First Team
| Jack Cunningham | Outfield | Paul VI |
| John McQuillen | Outfield | Gonzaga |
| Brian Tagoe | Outfield | St. John's |
| Joseph Goodwin | Infield | Good Counsel |
| A.J. Lee | Infield | St. John's |
| Patrick Ryan | Infield | Bishop O'Connell |
| Bryan Towers | Infield | St. Mary's Ryken |
| Jack Alkire | Pitcher | DeMatha Catholic |
| Stephen Schoch | Pitcher | Good Counsel |
| Rafi Vasquez | Pitcher | Bishop O'Connell |
| Devon Adams | Catcher | Paul VI |
| Ryan Scott | Utility | Bishop Ireton |
Player of the Year: Stephen Schoch (Good Counsel)
Coach of the Year: Tim Park (Good Counsel)
Second Team
| Chase Ragsdale | Outfield | Bishop McNamara |
| Josh Simon | Outfield | St. John's |
| Matt Flagg | Outfield | Gonzaga |
| Kyle Benjamin | Infield | Bishop McNamara |
| Jackson Covillo | Infield | St. John's |
| Matt Dorris | Infield | Gonzaga |
| Cam Remalia | Infield | St. John's |
| Robert Riddick | Pitcher | Paul VI |
| Andy Rozylowicz | Pitcher | DeMatha Catholic |
| Will Thomas | Pitcher | Gonzaga |
| Brett Simon | Catcher | St. John's |
| James DiGiulian | Utility | Bishop O'Connell |
Honorable Mention
Bishop Ireton: Chandler Wilder
Bishop McNamara: William Vickers, Elijah Hanible, Nick Washington
DeMatha: Chris Jeletic, Jarrett Faunce, Ellis Jones, Andrew Keith, Brad Thaxton, Aaron Brooks
Good Counsel: James Fitzgerald, Zach Papillo, Chris Sarvelson
Gonzaga: Michael Murray, Brendan Gibson, Cullen McGee, Ryan Donellan, George Casey
Paul VI: Matt Herzog, Michael Contz, Kevin Kelly, Yianni Tsiamis, Tim Newell
St John's: Ryan Olson, Ryan Wanner, Myles Mensah, Alex Taylor
St. Mary's Ryken: Joseph Sherman, Jacob Norris, Trevor Burch, Andrew Dameron