Posted: May 13, 2014
First Team
Player of the Year: Rafi Vazquez (Bishop O'Connell)
Coach of the Year: Jeff Nolan (Paul VI )
Second Team
Honorable Mention
Bishop Ireton: Seth Scalsky, Sam Ratner, Jimmy Swiger, Ryan Scott, Robert Corallo, Kyle Delaney, Sean Workman
Bishop McNamara: Tyler Gerald, Chase Ragsdale, Isaiah Chambers
Bishop O'Connell: Corey Burch
DeMatha: Michael Dunn, Chris Jeletic, Brad Thaxton
Good Counsel: Brett Weidemeyer, Joe Lozupone
Gonzaga: Ryan Leonard, James Orfini, David Mervis
St John's: Jake Bernstein, Jackson Coviello, Garrett Pearson
St. Mary's Ryken: Jacob Norris, Andrew Dameron
Paul VI: Robert Riddick, Clayton Blaine, Kevin Kelly, Yanni Tsiamis
| Myles Hudzick | Outfield | Bishop O'Connell |
| Brodie Leftwich | Outfield | St. John's |
| Andrew Page | Outfield | Paul VI |
| J.P. Boyle | Infield | Good Counsel |
| A.J. Lee | Infield | St. John's |
| Jack Morgan | Infield | Paul VI |
| Antonio Rosanova | Infield | DeMatha |
| Andy Rosylowicz | Pitcher | DeMatha |
| Stephen Schoch | Pitcher | Good Counsel |
| Connor Van Hoose | Pitcher | Gonzaga |
| Justin Morris | Catcher | DeMatha |
| Rafi Vazquez | Utility | Bishop O'Connell |
Coach of the Year: Jeff Nolan (Paul VI )
Second Team
| Michael Ficca | Outfield | Gonzaga |
| Andrew Keith | Outfield | DeMatha |
| Chase Travers | Outfield | St. Mary's Ryken |
| Michael Coritz | Infield | Paul VI |
| Adrian Peralta | Infield | St. John's |
| Ben Prada | Infield | DeMatha |
| Patrick Ryan | Infield | Bishop O'Connell |
| Jack Alkire | Pitcher | DeMatha |
| Brian Gilliam | Pitcher | St. Mary's Ryken |
| John Wiltshire | Pitcher | Paul VI |
| Drew Tessier | Catcher | Bishop O'Connell |
| John Cunningham | Utility | Paul VI |
Honorable Mention
Bishop Ireton: Seth Scalsky, Sam Ratner, Jimmy Swiger, Ryan Scott, Robert Corallo, Kyle Delaney, Sean Workman
Bishop McNamara: Tyler Gerald, Chase Ragsdale, Isaiah Chambers
Bishop O'Connell: Corey Burch
DeMatha: Michael Dunn, Chris Jeletic, Brad Thaxton
Good Counsel: Brett Weidemeyer, Joe Lozupone
Gonzaga: Ryan Leonard, James Orfini, David Mervis
St John's: Jake Bernstein, Jackson Coviello, Garrett Pearson
St. Mary's Ryken: Jacob Norris, Andrew Dameron
Paul VI: Robert Riddick, Clayton Blaine, Kevin Kelly, Yanni Tsiamis